Scars Of War (2) by GeckoYamori
Official Tiberian Sun Submission - 5th Place
Map Name: Scars Of War
Author: GeckoYamori
Site: Savage War (savagewar.co.uk), Project Perfect Mod (ppmsite.com), TiberiumSun.com
Best Rating On OMCs: <none>
Best Position On OMCs: <none>
Players: 2
Ratings:
Original Concept: 15.8%/20%
Ballance: 11.7/15%
Eye Candy: 23.4%/30%
Fun Factor: 12.2%/20%
Triggers: 8.4%/15%
-------------------------------------
Overall Score: 71.50%
Valid Score: 68.33%
Clazzy's Position: 5th - 74.0%
Wes.com's Position: 3rd - 63.0%
The DVD's Position: 9th - 62.5%
Python's Position: 2nd - 90.0%
Carnotaurus's Position: 5th - 68.0%
-------------------------------
Final Position: 5th
Comments (Note: all maps were submitted to judges anonymously to avoid biased reviews, so the judges had no idea of who submitted the map):
-> Clazzy:
- 16%
- 13%
- 23%
- 12%
- 10%
= 74%
Comments:
Nice layout, but far too many civilian buildings, since it was repetitive and limited build space.
Lighting is good, and the ion storm lighting is... different.
Ion storm not really suited to the level, to be honest.
AI didn't seem to attack me in the slightest, oddly enough.
-> Wes.com:
Original concept: 15/20
Balance: 13/15
Eyecandy: 15/30
Fun factor: 15/20
Triggers: 5/15 = 63%
good layout, but the city’s look like they r only made to fill up the place
it duse not look good
very little tiberium
-> TheDvD:
- (20%) Original Concept:
Weighted score: 10%
Category score: 50%
Not much to say. Some good things to see on this map.
- (15%) Balance:
Weighted score: 10,5%
Category score: 70%
This is good. Both bases have different weaknesses and strenghts. However, in the long run, the left base has a slight advantage, having more room to build.
- (30%) Eyecandy:
Weighted score: 25%
Category score: 83,3%
This map is very nice to look at. The lighting is very well done, albeit a bit funky. The detailing is nice and the setting is quite realistic.
- (20%) Fun Factor:
Weighted score: 14%
Category score: 67%
Solid fun.
- (15%) Triggers/Scripts:
Weighted score: 3%
Category score: 0%
There is an ion storm trigger.
- (100%) Total weighted score:
10+10,5+25+14+3=62,5%
-> Python:
Original Concept: 20/20 - Map is fantastic! Tons of detail and originality. Very realistic!
Balance: 14/15 - Tiberium was the same at both bases. Bases had equal building space. Spread out fairly.
EyeCandy: 28/30 - The city adds to the already amazing detail enclosed within this map. Although the same building side by side 5 times just doesn't look the best in some places.
Fun Factor: 15/20 - The Ion Storm added to this fun factor, you have to look after your base from the enemys and the storms! Quite annoying, though part of the game.
Triggers: 13/15 - Ion storms made a nice challanging map.
Overall Mark: 90%
-> Carnotaurus:
Original Concept: 18/20
Ballance: 08/15
Eye Candy: 26/30
Fun Factor: 05/20
Triggers: 11/15
---------
Score: 68/100
Original Concept: A city, wonderful. Map's small,obvously a ruined city, but it's nice to play. very well executed for a 'urban' map.
Balance:Both bases are nice, you should probably blow up the few civvie buildings left there, though. The key is controlling Tiberium, here!
Eyecandy:A nice shot at a city in the Firestorm world we love. ALOT of copy/paste work to improve the 'ruined' feeling. Some tiling errors that are hidden(untill you blow up buildings, though.). Totally stupid that there even are C&C 1 bases in a city, though.
Fun Factor: Depressing. the AI does NOT work at all(I have no idea why.),so you are pretty much free to explore the city against a comp. Humans are different. Just beware of neutral shiners, and a wolverine or two.
Triggers:Ion Storm with no lighting. Pretty depressing to see in action.
Map ReadMe Contents:
<none>
Contestant Words When Submitting:
- Creator: GeckoYamori
Sites I'm active in: www.ppmsite.com www.tiberiumsun.com
Map name: Scars of War (2)
Theme: Desert/Urban
Firestorm required: No.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Download it HERE.
This map can be mirrored by any participating site. Remember to credit the author of the map.
did u use TS:TX?
